A FURORE has erupted on social media over the design of Sutherland’s new flag, which was unveiled in the Northern Times last week.
The flag, showing a swooping eagle on a yellow and red background with three stars or "mullets", has been deemed ugly and questions have been raised over what it has to do with the county.
One Facebook user likened the flag to one of "an outer Mongolian third division football team" and another likened it to a "communist flag".
Carey Kerr posted: "It is horrific. The last place I think of when I see that flag is Sutherland. There is absolutely nothing Scottish about it. A very sad outcome."
Only two messages of support were left on our Facebook page for the flag. One of them, from Brady Ellis, said: "It’s not all that bad."
Sutherland’s Lord Lieutenancy team had organised the competition to find an image for a new flag that would "unify" the county.
There were 328 entries for the contest, which was launched last September and ended in November.
An 11-strong selection panel comprising members of the Lord Lieutenancy and representatives of youth and other groups across the county spent a day sifting through entries. They were guided by flag expert Philip Tibbett and heraldry expert Dr Joseph Morrow, the Lord Lyon of Scotland, who was present at the selection day.
At the time Vice Lord-Lieutenant Colin Gilmour said the panel had been very impressed with the standard of the designs with a wide variety of images submitted featuring deer, otters, eagle, wild cats and Highland cattle among other wildlife.
The judging panel eventually chose three winners with the final design an amalgam of all three.
The criticism of the design centres round the yellow and gold colour and the use of the eagle rather than a wildcat – seen to be the traditional emblem of Sutherland.
Brighter Brora secretary and former Brora Community Council chairman Kathleen Cunningham, wrote: "Somewhat disappointed. It’s way too strident and in no way reflects the atmosphere of Sutherland landscapes. How about green or purple for heather or blue?"
Retired primary school teacher Sheila Robertson posted: "Really don’t like the colour scheme – don’t feel it represents our beautiful landscape and palette."
Carly Macbeath urged organisers to go "back to the drawing board" while Lesley Fergus said the design was "not suitable at all". Mary Naylon posted that the swooping eagle looked more like a "budgie".
But Brady Ellis posted that red and gold were the armorial colours of the Earldom of Sutherland and the design was distinctive. Will Clark said it was "awesome".
Lt Col Colin Gilmour, spokesman for the flag selection committee, said it was inevitable that some comments on the final choice would be unfavourable. He pointed out that the lieutenancy organised the competition but did not have a deciding vote, instead the winning artwork was decided democratically and representation on the selection committee was from across Sutherland.
He said: "Importantly the young generation seem very enthusiastic about it. Feedback from the children and youth is overwhelmingly positive.
"In response to some of the comments raised, and for clarity, the following facts should to be considered.
"Regarding the wild cat, the land of the Cat is properly Caithness, not Sutherland. The original land of the Cat or ‘Cait’ (from about 800 AD) centred on Caithness and just included a small part of south-east Sutherland.
"The confusion comes from the Gaelic name for Sutherland which is ‘Cataibh’ which does indeed mean ‘cat land’ but it originated when south-east Sutherland and Caithness all fell under the one Pictish region.
"Unity of the county, especially including the west and north, was considered the key factor by the selection committee, so selecting an emblem that was historically limited to only a very small part of Sutherland (the south-east) and another adjacent county, might reasonably be considered to have been unrepresentative of the county as a whole.
"The eagle featured prominently on a considerable number of the entries, indeed much more so than the wild cat. Its current prominence in many parts of Sutherland was selected as a unifying factor across the county. Since the overwhelming factor in the design was ‘unity’, this is provided by the eagle.
"Regarding comments on the pose on the flag of the swooping eagle (head drawn in), this position is absolutely correct for a swooping eagle, though it did take considerable time to perfect it."
East Sutherland and Edderton ward councillor Jim McGillivray, who was on the selection committee, said: "To my mind it conveys an active and dynamic image that reflects ambition, purpose and indeed fierceness, set in colours that historically defined the House of Sutherland as the heraldic backdrop to the whole exercise, as was required by Lord Lyon.
"Personally, I am proud of ‘The Sutherland Eagle’.
"It has really grown on me the more I look at it."
What do you think of the
design? Email us your views to